A fair comparison
Comparing a loan payment with a card's minimum payment isn't fair, because minimums stretch payoff out for years. This calculator gives both options the same monthly payment, the loan's payment, so the difference you see comes from the rates and fees.
The loan is sized so that, after a deducted origination fee, you receive the full amount you need.
Example
$5,000 needed:
| Credit card (23.99%) | Personal loan (14%, 4% fee, 36 mo) | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | $178.03 | $178.03 |
| Paid off in | 42 months | 36 months |
| Interest + fees | $2,414 | $1,409 |
| APR | 23.99% | about 16.9% |
Other things to weigh
- Discipline: a loan's fixed end date forces payoff, while a card lets you pay less, which usually costs more.
- Credit impact: a new loan means a hard inquiry and a new account. Paying a card balance down can lower your utilization.
- Running the card back up: if you consolidate a card into a loan, keeping the card at zero is what makes it work.
Assumptions: card interest is calculated monthly at APR ÷ 12, with no new charges or fees.
Frequently asked questions
Is a personal loan cheaper than a credit card?
Often, when the loan's APR, with fees included, is well below the card's APR. In the default example, $5,000 costs about $1,409 in interest and fees on a 14% loan with a 4% fee, versus about $2,414 on a 23.99% card paid at the same $178 a month.
When is a credit card better?
For small amounts you can repay within a few months, or with a 0% promotional offer you'll fully pay off before it ends. Check balance-transfer fees and the rate that applies after the promotion.
Methodology last updated . The formulas are covered by automated tests. How we test our calculators.