What it compares
- Personal loan: unsecured, fixed rate, sized so you net the amount you need after an origination fee.
- HELOC: secured by your home, with a variable rate. It's modeled as fully amortizing payments over the period you choose, plus upfront costs. A rate-rise test re-amortizes the balance at a higher rate after year 1.
Example
$25,000 needed:
| Personal loan (12.5%, 3% fee, 5 yrs) | HELOC (8.5%, steady, 10 yrs) | HELOC (+2 pts after yr 1) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Payment | $579.86 | $309.96 | $309.96, then $334.98 |
| Interest + costs | $9,792 | $12,696 | $15,397 |
The HELOC payment is lower because the term is twice as long. That's also why it costs more in total.
Important limits of this model
Many HELOCs have an interest-only draw period followed by a repayment period with a higher payment. Rates follow an index, often the prime rate, plus a margin, and they can change many times. Read your HELOC agreement for caps, fees and the draw and repayment structure. Federal rules require lenders to give you specific HELOC disclosures. Read them before you sign.
Frequently asked questions
Is a HELOC cheaper than a personal loan?
A HELOC often has a lower starting rate because your home secures it. But its rate is usually variable, there may be upfront costs, and long repayment periods can raise the total cost. Most importantly, your home is at risk if you can't repay.
Why does the HELOC cost more in the example even with a lower rate?
Because it's repaid over 10 years instead of 5. At the same repayment period, the lower rate would usually cost less. Set both terms equal to see the rate effect on its own.
Methodology last updated . The formulas are covered by automated tests. How we test our calculators.